A new paper questions the advice to avoi

I'll look up the actual evidence and check the household cards before writing anything.

PASS. Here is the reply.

---

Short answer: current official advice for a 6–12-month-old is still no added salt — and the paper you read does not change that. It argues the evidence *behind* the rule is thin, which is a different claim.

What the evidence actually says

The paper is Yang et al., *Avoidance of added salt for 6–12-month-old infants: a narrative review*, Archives de Pédiatrie, 16 November 2023. Its abstract says three things:

• Most guidelines say avoid added salt at 6–12 months, but the *reason* for that rule lacks strong, reliable evidence.
• At 6–12 months the kidneys can excrete sodium adequately, and there is not enough evidence that higher salt intake this early causes high blood pressure or a lifelong preference for salty food.
• It also flags the opposite worry: a baby on completely unsalted complementary food could end up on the low side for sodium.

Two honest limits: it is a narrative review, not a trial — nobody added salt to babies and measured what happened; and I read its abstract and summary, not the full paywalled text. The part often left out of headlines is that it warns about getting salt *too* low, not that salt should be added.

Where official bodies actually stand, checked today:

• NHS (baby and toddler meal ideas; page last reviewed 21 Dec 2022, updated 8 Oct 2025): "When preparing food for babies, do not add sugar or salt (including stock cubes and gravy) directly to the food or to the cooking water."
• UK Scientific Advisory Committee on Nutrition, "Feeding in the first year of life": advised that the risks of added salt and free sugars in this age group need re-emphasising.
• UK government baby-food guidelines (published 22 August 2025): salt-reduction targets for commercial baby food, and no salt added for the 1–5 age band, with a numeric ceiling only from age 1.

So: no guideline body has changed on the back of this paper.

How much salt is "reasonable" for a 6–12-month-old

Zero added. Not "a pinch" — zero. She already gets sodium without any you add: breast milk or formula, bread, cheese, egg, meat, fish, vegetables. That is the whole recommendation.

The paper's low-sodium worry is not a reason to season the pot — it is a reason to raise the question at the next visit rather than to cook differently on your own. If anyone wants a number *for your baby*, that number has to come from your own paediatrician, and only if there is a reason: kidney disease, heart condition, hypertension risk, or a restricted diet. I will not put a published figure from another age band into your kitchen, because it would be a stranger's number applied to your child.

1. What you've tried vs better alternatives

One habit worth adding tonight: cook one unsalted base for everyone and season each plate at the table. It removes the whole decision from the cooking, saves a separate baby meal, and is one less thing to hold in your head during a school week.

2. Avoid list (kitchen and cupboard)

• No stock cubes, bouillon, gravy, soy sauce, fish sauce, curry paste or packet seasoning in anything she eats, including the cooking water.
• No food stored in brine or vinegar — olives, pickles, sauerkraut — as a "taste test".
• No adult salty snacks, salted nuts, pretzels or crisps; under 12 months she does not need snacks between meals, so this is mostly about other people handing things over.
• If anyone in the house uses a low-sodium salt substitute containing potassium, keep it out of the shared pot and ask her clinician before it ever appears near her food.
• No bought supplements, powders or anything from an online pharmacy to "balance" sodium.
• Don't change anything about her medicines or feeds on the back of this either.

What this guide does not do: it does not diagnose anything, it does not change her medicines or feeds, and it does not give you a number to cook to — those come from your own clinician, who can see her.

3. Decision tree — run it once, tonight

A. Has she had a salty thing in one go — a whole stock cube, a fistful of crisps, a big lick of gravy, something salty from the counter?
→ Yes: this is no longer a diet question. Call your local poison centre or emergency number now, keep the packet, do not make her vomit. Give me your city and I'll find the right number. No → B.

B. Feeding normally, alert, usual wet nappies?
→ Yes: keep the no-added-salt routine, save one note for the next visit. No → C.

C. Fewer wet nappies than usual, pulling away from food, pale, unusually sleepy, or you simply can't shake the worry
→ book a visit in the next few days — a test weight and a look at her, not a phone call about salt. Ask them to weigh her and to note kidney/heart history as background, not as a salt issue.

D. Anyone has ever been told she needs a specific sodium plan (kidney, heart, blood pressure, restricted diet)
→ that plan wins, and it comes from that clinician — not from a headline, not from me.

Red flags — stop the kitchen plan, get help now

Call your local emergency number or go to emergency care now if she has:

• hard to wake, will not feed at all, limp or floppy, or a weak or high-pitched cry
• laboured or fast breathing, or blue lips
• a temperature of 38 °C or above, feeling hot or cold to touch, or a temperature that keeps changing
• green (bile-stained) vomit, or blood in the stool
• markedly fewer wet nappies than usual, or a deeply sunken soft spot on the head
• a rash that does not fade when you press a clear glass firmly against it
• any fit or jerking episode
• after a possible high-salt swallow: vomiting, drowsiness, or any of the above

Don't wait to see if it passes. Don't force food or drink into a baby who will not drink or is not fully awake. These are reasons to be seen, not things to manage at the stove.

What success looks like in 24 hours (no cures promised)

• One pot cooked, her portion lifted out before any salt went in.
• No stock cube, bouillon or gravy in her portion.
• One label checked if you used a tin or jar tonight.
• The salt pot lives on the adults' side only.
• She ate the family dinner — same food, less seasoned — and nothing was worse than yesterday.
• One note saved for the next visit.

Scripts to screenshot

To the family / grandparent offering salty snacks
> "She's having the same dinner as us — it just comes off before the salt goes in. No added salt at her age, and we keep it low afterwards too. Plain toast or banana and she's happy."

To the elder or sibling who is cooking
> "Stock cubes and gravy, no — those go in after her bowl is filled. Plain veg, rice, egg, fish, and I'll mash it. If she wants a second helping tonight, just more of the same."

To whoever sent you the paper
> "It's a review arguing the evidence for the no-salt rule is thin. It doesn't say add salt, and it warns the other way too — about too *little*. NHS and SACN still say no added salt at 6–12 months."

To the paediatrician or GP at the next visit
> "We cook one unsalted family meal and take her portion out before seasoning. We've read that the evidence for avoiding salt is weak. Given her history, is there any reason to add salt or check sodium for her? And what should change at 12 months?"

One question so I can be more exact

How old is she in months — and has anyone already given her something salty in one go (a whole stock cube, a big handful of crisps, a lick of gravy)? If you give me your city too, I'll have the right local poison-centre and emergency door to hand.

What I could not check: the full text of the review (paywalled), the WHO and EU infant-feeding pages (behind a verification screen), and any doctor-recorded note about her own sodium or kidney history — if you have a clinic summary at home, that page settles the last point better than anything I can read. I also could not verify which journal page you saw the summary on; if the version you were sent quotes a figure as a *target*, bring it to the visit rather than cooking to it.